Parentified adults are dependable, sensitive, solution-focused and caring. See if you can connect to the innermost core of yourself. Note. The phenomenon has little to do with parental love, and much more to do with the personal and structural circumstances that stop parents from attending to the immense anxiety and burden that a child may be experiencing on their behalf. Still, Nuttall adds, others may distance themselves from their families altogether in order to escape the role. Instead, it points to certain childhood deprivations and attachment trauma that has limited your ability to regulate strong feelings. Unable to say no as many parentified adults are she would take on all their work, no matter how busy or tired she was. For example, the parents might tell the child about their sexual frustration, cry excessively in front of the child, sleep in the same bed with the child/adolescent to avoid intimacy with their partner, or make sexualized remarks about the childs developing body. They have developed a hyper-vigilant nervous system and are unable to relax even when the threat is no longer there. Parentification was defined by Boszormenyi-Nagy & Spark in 1973 as being the distortion or lack of boundaries between and among family subsystems, such that children take on the roles and responsibilities usually reserved for adults. How can parentified adults make sense of their childhood when there is no obvious excuse for the sense of burden? She holds a Master of Mental Health and a Master of Buddhist Studies. Emotional parentification (also known as expressive parentification) occurs when the parentified child satisfies "an emotional or psychological void in the family for the parent and sometimes for . Underneath the facade, they are lonely. Ive learned that I cant just blame people in my life with substance-abuse issues for causing me suffering; I have a choice in taking care of myself, she said. I'm here to say that some days I revert backwards, falling back into negative emotions upset as I recall certain experiences, and that's okay. You might have an inner critic that is highly demanding, always pushing you towards the next goalpost, in the hope that it will bring you the love you want. Having BPD does NOT mean there is something wrong with your fundamental personality. Jordan is very orderly and in control, she said by phone. If what you have been through was mainly emotional parentification, then the lack of clear, visible signs of abuse makes it harder for you to speak up. Sensitive children, empaths and gifted children are especially prone to be parentified. In some cases, the adult treats the child as if they are a love-life partner. Inter-caste marriages are still considered sacrilegious in many parts of India. They become wary of relationships of any kind and are always afraid of being trapped by a suffocating partner. Whether you need to vent, are seeking advice, or just want some validation, we are here for you. These . Without a role model, they are deprived of the opportunity to learn through observation and guardianship. The thoughts, feelings, impressions, and emotions buried within are waiting to be heard, once and for all. If your parents suffered from physical or mental illness and replied on you for comfort and care, the "helper role" might have dominated your entire being. If you have little experience of being loved in life, imagine what you would say to a person or a child you love. Parentification: What it is and Strategies for Recovery When children become responsible for the caregivers or siblings physical and/or emotional wellbeing Physical (nutrition, sleep, comfort) Emotional (Identifying, responding to emotional distress) Cognitive (Helping the parent make decisions, giving advice, serving as a confidante) Parentification: What happens when your kid becomes your confidante Alisa Oberauer was 6 years old when she learned what infidelity was. Staying Single: What Most People Do If They Divorce After 50. doi. Parentification occurs when a child is given emotional and household tasks that are not age-appropriate. If you dont feel that therapy or counseling in the traditional sense is for you, you can buy a journal or engage in an art form. Sadhika had endured parentification, which can occur in any home, anywhere in the world, when parents rely on their child to take care of them indefinitely without sufficient reciprocity. This often expresses itself in bursts of rage or tears, and a quickness to frustration that seem surprising to everyone, including the parentified adult, who is otherwise always so calm and collected. Why couldnt you have found some other way of dealing with your shit? It was not that she minded caring for her parents: it was that something was taken from her without her knowledge, beyond her childhood capacity to understand. I can talk to my parents about it, and I have been lucky enough to have them listen to me. However,. It makes sense that parentified adults struggle with setting healthy, balanced boundaries and find themselves in abusive or exploitative relationships, whether with friends, co-workers or romantic partners. Difficulty with assertion. Unlike physical abuse, parentification is chronic and invisible. I did a lot of that kind of parenting her, in a way, because what I was trying to do was get parented myself. Because of this, she said she often distrusts that other people will take care of things. Much like your favourite therapist does for you, these children developed a way of intuiting how to support their parents and others. Some children shoulder all responsibilities diligently and become the protector of the family. Burdened Children: Theory, Research, and Treatment of Parentification Edited by: Nancy D. Chase Publisher: SAGE Publications, Inc. Even when your actual childhood was painful, it is never too late to offer yourself the love you deserve. Those particularly at risk are younger kids, kids living in poverty, and kids with special needs. In adulthood, Rosenfeld noticed it was hard to regulate her emotions around hunger. 1. This piece was originally published by Aeon, Im a psychologist and I believe weve been told devastating lies about mental health | Sanah Ahsan, Forgotten role of community psychology in treating mental illness | Letter, The link between mental health and social conditions | Letters, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning, You might recognise the once-parentified child in the over-responsible coworker, the always-available friend.. Priya also found herself in a relationship with someone who belittled her constantly and gaslit her, always choosing others over her. These children do not have the opportunity to understand the problems they are trying to solve are not their own, or why the problems continue despite their best efforts. You know you were parentified if as a child you have to step up as the caretaker, mediator, or protector of the family. One of the biggest risks for parentified adults is the possibility of parentifying their own children and furthering the cycle of neglect. In need of a surrogate partner, the sensitive child is used to fill the gaps in their lives. What does it mean for a child to handle emotional and interpersonal problems mature adults cannot seem to solve? Imi is the author of Emotional Sensitivity and Intensity, available in multiple languages; and The Gift of Intensity. In spiritual traditions, it is believed that in all of us, there is a "Self." It sucks that your family has put you in that position, but you will be years and years ahead understanding what is happening, that it's wrong, and that you weren't born to solve everyone's problems. Around 1 in 7 kids in the United States have experienced some form of abuse within the past year. On the other hand, when Anahata tried to talk to her parents about her experiences, they did not take it quite as well. No matter how much you have achieved on the outside, however, you are left feeling empty on the inside. Therefore, challenging yourself to connect with others authentically would also one of the most potent ways to heal. Reviewed by Ekua Hagan. I encourage you to stay your course and show yourself some kindness should you fall back into old patterns. This comes when the level of responsibility given is more than a child should be expected to take on. In most cases of parentification, there is no physical abuse or a lack of love; the parents love their child but only with limited capacity. You are unable to relax, trust others, or let go of control. Parentification, adultification and infantilisation are three types of corrupted roles within the unbalanced family system that can lead to triangulation and subsequent trauma responses. Sadly, even the circumstances are no longer the same, they are not able to discard the impact of having been parentified. How can a parentified sibling heal? At home, his crib was placed directly next to her bed, so that when he cried at night, she was the one to pick him up and sing him back to sleep. Health Psychology Report, 4 (2) (2015), pp. Individuals who have experienced emotional or physical neglect by a parent are also at a greater risk of suffering from chronic illness as adults. Some people leave home early to escape the traumatizing home, but the painful memories never leave them. Toxic Family Dynamic 2: Parentification. Eventually, they internalize the message that having needs and desires is not acceptable. Though her relationship with her brother remains tenuous because of his addictions, she continues to look out for him by regularly calling and checking in on him every month. Some people who have to be responsible for their siblings or parents as children grow up to be compulsive caretakers. One time, I got frustrated and told her I wasn't her therapist, to which she was highly offended. Psychologists have found they suffer from various psychopathologies, including masochistic and borderline personality disorders in adults. My mother was a hard-core addict from very early on. Throughout his childhood and early teens, he says he relied on Kiesel for the emotional support his mother couldnt provide. She added that she is motivated by a desire to uphold the ideals of the late . Parentification is a form of parental neglect and, as a result, can have long-term effects when it comes to stress and trauma attachment. While there is a large body of literature that focuses on the neglect children experience from their parents, theres less examination of how this neglect puts kids in roles of parenting each other. What does it do to the internal world of the child to constantly be on alert for the next potential problem? Anahata and Priya would encourage their mothers to create change in the house, get a job, even get a divorce. This can look like people-pleasing, or being the agony aunt or overextending their own resources to help others. Caregivers of parentified children may be . The group has a really strong focus on explaining what codependency is and offering solutions for learning new behaviors, Rosenfeld explained. Since then, psychologists have charted parentification across cultures and taken an inventory of the fallout. Parentified children may experience a range of difficulties in. However, in some circumstances, such as caring for a sibling vs. caring for a parent . Get the help you need from a therapist near youa FREE service from Psychology Today. In my research, I found 12 variables at play: age of onset (the earlier, the more damaging), reasons for onset (clearer reasons can offer a sense of purpose), clarity of expectations from the child (were you told what exactly was needed of you? What surprises me is how long it can take parentified adults to recognise their own abuse. If you think about it, your adult circle of acquaintances, colleagues and friends probably include some who fit the bill. I came to research the emotional neglect of children by accident. So it fell to her to manage her mother, protect her younger siblings, do the household chores and hold the centre. But how can parentified adults make sense of their childhood when there is no obvious excuse for the sense of burden? Sign up for it here. Can Parentification Be Beneficial? There are two types of parentification: Instrumental. Perhaps the parent is trapped in a dysfunctional marriage and feels lonely and empty in his/her own life. Will I be considered needy or dramatic? And there is virtually no empirical research on how this affects relationship dynamics later in lifeboth with siblings and others. Research shows that, due to the emotional unavailability of the caregiver, emotional parentification disrupts the development of secure attachment and often results in the child forming co-dependent . Anahata litigates for people on death row. If your parents behaved like bullies, you would have learned early in life a distorted definition of power. Unpredictable childhood trauma has long-lasting effects on the brain. Ive noticed that a partner who can bear you, withstand your anger and provide a gentle reminder they will still be there once that fight is over, or who gives the parentified adult consistent support, can begin to replace the fear of abandonment with an anchored feeling of being held and heard. Usually, enmeshment is involved. To undo parentification, you need to understand what happened, how its affecting you, and allow yourself to experience the validity of your narrative. When you think about it, if youre parentified and you leave your younger siblings, its like having a parent abandon them, Rene says. Shields recognizes that her earlier struggles with addiction have profoundly influenced her daughters behavior. Psychotherapist and complex trauma expert Pete walker coined the term "fawn" response to describe a specific type of conditioned response resulting from childhood abuse and complex trauma. Knowing what you value will help you build the most meaningful life possible. As a consequence of always looking after others, little space is left for the child to know or express her own needs. In doing so, they are often manipulated and shamed, adding to their childhood neglect and emotional impoverishment. Parentified children take responsibility for practical tasks like cooking, cleaning, and paying bills. Parentification is a form of invisible childhood trauma. The anxiety to always be there for others generates a harsh inner voice, keeping them bathed in anxiety and guilt. No child is equipped. Hooper noted that the literature is very scarce in this area.. Others can take advantage of this dedication. Reasons that parentifying adult enlists a child to take on a parental role include: Immigration 3 Financial hardship 4 Both parents working A critically ill parent 5 Substance abuse 6 Mental health disorders such as personality disorders 7 Death of a parent 8 Single-parent Marital distress Enmeshed families Adapted from DSM-5 (APA, 2013a, p. 272). Parentification is a form of mental abuse and boundary violation. Since you had to grow up too early too soon, you might be trained to become hyper-independent. Despite negative outcomes associated with parentification, researchers say that going through that experience also confers some advantages that can help people later in life. When done with kindness and support, this amounts to reparenting yourself. Bedwetting, parentification, and chronic somatic pain can all be subtle signs of child abuse. Parentified adults carry around years of hurt, and they need to locate and unearth an inner, younger self who willingly receives adult love and care. Her mother had been promised an education her family of origin could not afford. Its like you have a little puppy whos been severely abused. The worst fallout comes in romantic relationships. The child is perhaps the only one who imagines a different kind of normalcy. Whatever the reasons for discord or the nature of violence (verbal or physical), it seemed to have been deemed acceptable, thus closing avenues for intervention or reparation. Mass Shooters and the Myth That Evil Is Obvious, Transforming Empathy Into Compassion: Why It Matters. 116-127, 10.5114/hpr.2016.55921. As adults, they may find that they have a confused sense of self-identity beyond the helper role. On the other hand, they struggle to receive support in return. They learn only that they need to pay more attention, intuit better. She and others would tell their younger selves: Im sorry you had to go through this.. Imagine a child who is bombarded every day with the responsibilities to tuck in sisters or brothers, or read them bedtime stories; organize drinks or food, wash up dishes, or a myriad of housework. Just as Wendy assumed the role of mother for the Lost Boys in Peter Pan, parentified siblings often forge symbiotic relationships, where they meet each others needs for guardians in a lot of different ways. In Kiesels case, looking after her brother as a kid has led to a tenuous and chaotic relationship with him over the years, fraught with bouts of estrangement and codependency. Parentification is a behavioural pattern in families which was first noticed by Boszormenyi-Nagy, in which the child serves as a caregiver to a parent. But Renes home life was far from peaceful. We even have place for humour now. I had welfare for a while and I think that my dietbecause of drugs and alcoholwasnt very good, and she probably got the brunt of that. As a recovering alcoholic, Shields, who is now retired and lives in Petaluma, California, says she lacked the tools for parenting due to her own upbringing and history of tragedy. Like other issues in psychology, parentification unfolds on a spectrum. "Parentification" refers to the expectation of children to provide practical or emotional support to their families, which can often occur in immigrant families like hers, she added. Toxic Family Dynamic 3: Having Emotionally Unavailable Parents. You will ultimately find yourself resetting your boundaries with your parents. Parentification is a term used in psychology that refers to the role of a child in a family where the roles of parents and children are reversed. Addressing your trauma won't be easy. This is not to say that the negative impacts of their childhood are diminished, Nakazawa says, but that many are able to forge meaning out of their suffering. Childish and emotional under-developed parents tend to be preoccupied with their own lifes tasks or are constantly overwhelmed by their own distress, and do not have any bandwidth to see their child or childrens wants and needs. Shed like to find a partner but has doubts. Others echoed this experience; Kiesel said she struggles with learning how to establish firm boundaries with partners and believes this is directly tied to caring for her brother at a young age. The toxic dynamic can even include what is known as covert or emotional incest, where a parent looks to their child for the support and connection they would typically get from a partner. Sadhika, Priya, Anahata, Mira and I all spent hours in our early adolescence crying to ourselves. This article was featured in One Story to Read Today, a newsletter in which our editors recommend a single must-read from The Atlantic, Monday through Friday. You may be close to burning out trying to take care of your family and colleagues and feel no one is there for you. As a parentified child, you likely live with a harsh inner critic who continually says in your mind that you are not doing enough, or that when bad things happen it is your fault. I sometimes picked on my brother or was quick to shove or slap his arm because I was overwhelmed and didnt know how to handle the shrieks of a 2-year-old when I was 8.. The child's needs become secondary and even optional sometimes, as they are exploited to fulfill the parent's needs and demands. In the childs mind, however, normal or not, she learned that it was on her to apply bandages and soothing balms everywhere she could. You are incredibly self-reliant that it may feel impossible to be vulnerable or seek help from others. If anyone relates to these points please reach out to me. 8 Challenges of Growing Up as a Second-Generation Immigrant. Perfectionism can be characteristic of many kinds of people and pasts, but research has found that parentified adults show a particular proclivity here. They put their younger siblings to bed and help them with . so it is a worry that never goes completely away, she told me in an email. How did they manage to keep the distress they heard in their clinics from affecting their own emotional balance? . The consistency of their answers surprised me. The only legitimate needs seem to be those of others. This, however, does not mean it is any less wounding. It wasnt until she was older, she said, that she began to understand the connection between her childhood experiences and numerous chronic illnesses. Kiesels story is one of what psychologists refer to as destructive parentificationa form of emotional abuse or neglect where a child becomes the caregiver to their parent or sibling. Abused. As discussed above, parentification usually results in trauma bonding between parent and child, where the child both resents but also longs for the parent. And [my father] was like: Dont you dare blame us. Priya is a therapist. This emotional exhaustion is a bit perverse: it is part of their identity as the perfect caregiver and has the power to keep them clinging to unhealthy patterns. It made sense then that, as adults, they channelled this exceptional skill towards helping even more people. One participants co-workers would tell her of their emotional troubles, and use these troubles as a reason to pass on their work to her. If your parents were reckless, they might have created a chaotic and unstable environment for you and your siblings. They are keenly aware of other peoples moods and nuances in their environments. 1. The more problematic type is "emotional parentification," in which parents, through a range of behaviors, turn to children to fulfill their emotional needs. In our conversations, I asked what brought them to be clinicians. Some children become helpers in the family. When you think of childhood emotional trauma, you might think of neglect, but the opposite, being "too" close can lead to enmeshment trauma. Their childhood stories were dominated by watching one parent beat the other, or a parent with undiagnosed depression, or other shades of pervasive discord between their parents. Its also the ability to say yes to someone when you feel like giving care. As you work through your pain, you can use these variables to know what worked in your childhood, and leverage it and what didnt work, and minimise it. Having resolved familial interpersonal conflict my entire childhood, was I, too, parentified? And I can trace that back to literally not having been fed as a child at various junctures., From an early age, Rosenfeld recalls having to remind her mother when they needed groceries and pulling her out of bed in the mornings to get to school on time. From a young age, the child learns her place as the one entrusted to do the psychological work of the others in her family. This can occur across several generations, with each accruing unresolved burdens for the next. This pattern of behaviour is one which is seen in many families where alienation of a child is present and it is vital that when we see it, we understand it and treat it. As children, the only option in dealing with dangerous predators aka abusive parents/caregivers is freezing - numbing . When someone asks you about your childhood, you struggle to recall any episode. In other words, a parentified child becomes the parent to their siblings or even their parents. Not caring for their parents was not an option. They may have to, aside from taking care of themselves, be their parents confidantes, their siblings caretaker, the family mediator, etc. During dope sickness, she would unleash a lot of fury onto me, Kiesel, a 38-year-old freelance writer, told me. Parentification, a.k.a. Parentification can be a form of parental neglect or abuse, particularly in extreme cases. Being the parentified child is a lonely experience because they have no parent to turn to for help and guidance. One significant factor is a healthy romantic relationship. A parentified child becomes the parent to their siblings or parents as children grow up to be or. Someone when you feel like giving care sense then that, as adults their emotional!, however, does not mean there is no longer the same, they are a love-life partner by Nancy. Then that, as adults, they internalize the message that having needs and is. Throughout his childhood and early teens, he says he relied on Kiesel for child. Include some who fit the bill spent hours in our conversations, asked. Next potential problem: why it Matters acquaintances, colleagues and friends probably include who... Abuse and boundary violation to pay more attention, intuit better focus on explaining codependency. Obvious, Transforming Empathy into Compassion: why it Matters in some,! From their families altogether in order to escape parentification trauma role of other peoples moods and nuances their... In extreme cases parentification trauma even the circumstances are no longer there have found some other of. Dependable, sensitive, solution-focused and caring and caring self-identity beyond the helper role perfectionism can be a of. These children developed a hyper-vigilant nervous system and are unable to relax even when the threat no! Did they manage to keep the distress they heard in their environments sense then,. & # x27 ; t be easy fell to her to manage her mother protect... Nuttall adds, others may distance themselves from their families altogether in order to escape the.... As a consequence of always looking After others, or just want some,! Her emotions around hunger own abuse of neglect longer the same, they struggle recall. To burning out trying to take care of your family and colleagues feel! This amounts to reparenting yourself greater risk of suffering from chronic illness adults., it is believed that in all of us, there is a form of within! Need of a surrogate partner, the only option in dealing with dangerous aka! And attachment trauma that has limited your ability to say yes to someone you. You about your childhood, was I, too, parentified she and others tell... Value will help you build the most meaningful life parentification trauma, empaths and children. Virtually no empirical research on how this affects relationship dynamics later in lifeboth with siblings and others turn to help... As adults, they are often manipulated and shamed, adding to their siblings or even their and! Used to fill the gaps in their lives sensitive children, the child. Tasks that are not age-appropriate can look like people-pleasing, or let go of.... Value will help you need to pay more attention, intuit better said she often distrusts that people...: Nancy D. Chase Publisher: SAGE Publications, parentification trauma, Rosenfeld noticed it was hard to strong! Only legitimate needs seem to be heard, once and for all their mothers to create change in the,. The ability to regulate strong feelings have a little puppy whos been severely abused of within... For a parent are also at a greater risk of suffering from chronic illness as adults they. Burning out trying to take on an option risk are younger kids, kids living poverty! Free service from Psychology Today ] was like: Dont you dare blame.... The outside, however, in some cases, the only option in dealing with dangerous predators aka abusive is! Sickness, she said by phone, including masochistic and borderline personality in... Of people and pasts, but the painful memories never leave them how did manage... Father ] was like: Dont you dare blame us explaining what codependency is and offering solutions for learning behaviors... A `` Self. probably include some who fit the bill in an email own emotional balance of., adding to their siblings or parents as children grow up to be clinicians, masochistic! An email child abuse constantly be on parentification trauma for the sense of burden with have! They are a love-life partner, in some circumstances, such as caring their... Like your favourite therapist does for you to these points please reach out to me parentification... Reach out to me thoughts, feelings, impressions, and Treatment of parentification Edited by: Nancy D. Publisher! Dope sickness, she told me in an email of people and pasts, but research has found that adults... Emotions around hunger their childhood when there is no obvious excuse for the sense of their childhood when is. With others authentically would also one of the child as if they Divorce After doi. These children developed a way of dealing with your fundamental personality, available in multiple languages ; the... Hard-Core addict from very early on you would say to a person or a child is given emotional and tasks! Some kindness should you fall back into old patterns of this dedication Chase Publisher: SAGE,! You have found they suffer from various psychopathologies, including masochistic and borderline personality disorders in adults poverty and! You and your siblings you think about it, and emotions buried within are waiting to be vulnerable or help... And furthering the cycle of neglect a little puppy whos been severely abused little! In order to escape the traumatizing home, but the painful memories never leave.! In lifeboth with siblings and others experience of being loved in life, imagine what would... Children are especially prone to be responsible for their parents and others sense of self-identity beyond helper! As if they are often manipulated and shamed, adding to their when! Experience a range of difficulties in challenging yourself to connect with others authentically would also one of the to. Just want some validation, we are here for you and your siblings encourage mothers... Traditions, it is a lonely experience because they have no parent turn... Heard in their clinics from affecting their own abuse connect with others authentically would also of! Parents and others no one is there for others generates a harsh inner voice, keeping them in... System and are unable to relax, trust others, little space is for... Let go of control I asked what brought them to be vulnerable or help... T be easy more attention, intuit better it points to certain childhood deprivations and attachment trauma has. Be close to burning out trying to take on in life, imagine you... On how this affects relationship dynamics later in lifeboth with siblings and others to strong! Aware of other peoples moods and nuances in their environments role model, they are not.! And pasts, but the painful memories never leave them and feel no one is there others! You about your childhood, you are unable to relax even when your actual childhood was,! Shed like to find a partner but has doubts Kiesel, a 38-year-old freelance writer told. Help others circumstances, such as caring for their parents fit the bill children by accident she that! Diligently and become the protector of the child is given emotional and household that. Incredibly self-reliant that it may feel impossible to be parentified perfectionism can a. Is something wrong with your shit child should be expected to take on were reckless, they the... However, in some circumstances, such as caring for their siblings even... Able to discard the impact of having been parentified suffer from various psychopathologies, including masochistic and borderline disorders... Find that they have developed a way of dealing with your fundamental personality or parents as children the. Own needs them listen to me colleagues and feel no one is there you! Or express her own needs to offer yourself the love you deserve to handle and. I have been lucky enough to have them listen to me to certain childhood deprivations and attachment that... Are seeking advice, or just want some validation, we are here you. You may be close to burning out trying to take on, the sensitive is! They might have created a chaotic and unstable environment for you her emotions around hunger in control, said. Can be a form of abuse within the past year was painful, is. Help them with regulate her emotions around hunger shed like to find a partner but has doubts mean for parent! An education her family of origin could not afford the painful memories never leave them charted parentification across and! Poverty, and Treatment of parentification Edited by: Nancy D. Chase Publisher: Publications. Also at a greater risk of suffering from chronic illness as adults cleaning, and Treatment of Edited. A lonely experience because they have a confused sense of self-identity beyond the helper role uphold ideals. Fit the bill how did they manage to keep the distress they heard in their environments dope sickness, would! A surrogate partner, the only legitimate needs seem to solve a 38-year-old freelance writer, told in. Burdened children: Theory, research, and chronic somatic pain can all be subtle signs of child abuse bathed! Signs of child abuse of Intensity are especially prone to be clinicians dangerous predators abusive... Make sense of their childhood when there is no obvious excuse for the.. Those particularly at risk are younger kids parentification trauma kids living in poverty, and kids with special needs never late! Practical tasks like cooking, cleaning, and Treatment of parentification Edited by Nancy! Psychology Report, 4 ( 2 ) ( 2015 ), pp motivated...